[[Warning Containing Rant]] I’m joining Dan in his Amazon crusade (see here and here), which basically means, I’m not selling books on there (I pulled all my for sale books down today from their site), and I’m not buy books from there (unless maybe there’s the one long lost used Quaker book I absolutely need and cannot find in any library or anywhere else).1 I’m not one to be too dogmatic but I do think it’s about time to put my foot down on this. A while back Dan challenged me on my usage of Amazon affiliate links on my blog, a practice I never really felt great about but had my (somewhat justified) reasons for doing so. I make a decent amount of money on my blog every month from book sales and text-link-ads to help defray the cost of my school book budget, so while I pretty much never buy new books from Amazon, I felt that making a little cash off a sale wasn’t a bad deal. But then he showed me that you can do the affiliate links elsewhere (Powell’s) and so I decide to stop link to Amazon books.2
So that’s part one. Part two is really the point of my boycott.
If you’ve ever watched “The Trip” on Six Feet Under from season one, you’ll have a good picture of what I’m about to say: it’s the episode where David and Nate go to the funeral home director’s conference and it’s completely vacant just reminding them of how difficult a situation their own family (funeral) business is in. The other day my boss (I work at an independent bookstore), during our weekly staff meeting, told us about the recent Independent Bookseller’s conference that happened in LA last week. This annual conference is a chance for indie booksellers to get together, buy some cheap books, go to workshops and stay up on the latest and greatest. It’s usually a big deal. Except this year. My boss said it was an absolute ghost-town. She said, there just aren’t any independent bookstores left. Problem is everyone’s going out of business due to the big corporate booksellers, especially big bad Amazon (my words not hers). She also said that the keynote was by some big whig at Amazon, are you kidding me (this is the same exact thing that happened in the SFU episode)?! She also told us that (some of) the publishers are now realizing just how guilty they are in this whole thing (now they see they’ve created a monster).
See publishers have been cutting Amazon “sweetheart deals” for sometime, that is they’ve been giving Amazon discounts (10-15% extra) that they would never give an independent bookstore. This was because of the bulk Amazon could push. But of course, in the process, they’ve helped to run these small bookshops out of town. Plus, they’ve created their own little Frankenstein. Well, the trouble is now Frankenstein wants to control the print-on-demand business as well (which is increasingly becoming more popular), so if you’re a publisher and you don’t let Amazon run your print on demand for you, there’s a real good chance they’ll just decide not to sell your books online. The tables have turned. Now the publishers need amazon, just as much as the dying independent bookstores needed help from the publishers to ward off the evil giant.
So at our little religious bookstore we too have been loosing more money every year and things aren’t getting any better (I wish I had a dollar for every time a student or customer came into our bookstore and told other customers to get all their books on Amazon, I might actually be able to help the business out a little more!). We keep wondering how long we’ll be around, or what it’s going to take to turn the corner. We’ve been cutting hours, and trying to carry different types of stock that people can’t buy on Amazon (which is very little). It’s sad because both my bosses have been at this for more than 20 years, and they’re really good at it. Our bookstore is one of the best theological bookstores in the US, no joke. And hearing their story about this past weekend really drove it home for me.
So if you’re the kind of person that really digs books, and likes your local bookshops, boycott Amazon and the other corporates as well. If you do buy your books online check out these instead:
- Abesbooks
- Powell’s (who you can do affiliates with as well)
- Half.com
- Alibris
- This post has a lot of helpful sites for trading and sharing books.
Local bookstores for those of you in Pasadena:
- Vroman’s (an incredible independent bookstore in Pasadena)
- Fuller’s Bookstore
- Archives (great religious used books)
- Book Alley (mostly used and rare books but also new)
Bookstores suggested by GL readers:
[Post edited Monday June 9th 8am]
Footnotes- In actuality I have literally under 10 (new) books from Amazon out of my entire library [↩]
- At this point I don’t think I am going to go back through all of my old posts and remove my amazon affiliate links just because that would take a ridiculous amount of time. But all new links will be affiliate links to Powell’s or non-affiliate links elsewhere. [↩]
- In actuality I have literally under 10 (new) books from Amazon out of my entire library [↩]
- At this point I don’t think I am going to go back through all of my old posts and remove my amazon affiliate links just because that would take a ridiculous amount of time. But all new links will be affiliate links to Powell’s or non-affiliate links elsewhere. [↩]
Related posts:
- Let’s have an Amazon.com-free Christmas this year
- A Good Place to Start: Žižek on Lacan (Book Reviews)
- Books for Sale
Dan, I don’t understand your last sentence. What I feel I’m being told is that I should support small bookstores just because. What I’m trying to say is my convictions come from being a writer and a book lover.
I’m not worried about the book publishing/selling industry precisely because the books that are being affected by Amazon were never, and would never, be carried by small bookstores anyhow. Small bookstores, the majority of them that aren’t offering used books/etc. have long been the power brokers, and now their power is broken I’m not feeling very much regret unless small bookstores respond in a way that justifies their continued participation in the community.
Small bookstores have mass market books. They are not boutique stores. Small presses have always struggled. But my small press isn’t helped whatsoever by small bookstores. I sell books on Amazon. Small bookstores look at me, even when I have a glossy sheet in hand, and “will get back to me”. However, if they are the ones struggling then they need to have the strength of their convictions and be proactive in seeking out participation in the community.
Amazon, and other online sellers, has been a huge boon to writers and the book community by allowing a marketplace for people who have something to say but who were laughed at or ignored by bookstores. So, I don’t feel a lot of loyalty, even if I really can see how a small bookstore might become a tremendous asset.
The issue for me here is books. Books and writers. How these are sold is not primary. Bookstores are middlemen, displaying a book for a reader. The less we have to depend on more middlemen deciding what is and what is not acceptable for their community the better chance we have to get messages out there. It’s hard for me to see how small bookstores alleviate mass marketing when mass marketed books are the only ones they will sell.
Get these stores to feature new and local and distinct writers and maybe they’ll find a place. Right now they have an equivalent of a Christendom attitude. So long they have been in control of reading they still, without adapting, expect people to just show up, and still leave a whole lot of writers and publishers out in the cold.
Distribution and access has become immensely better with Amazon. I know that personally and with many other small writers. I haven’t yet heard a reason for convictions other than a distaste for Amazon’s size.
Meanwhile they sell books of people I know and my book. That’s distribution and access for those otherwise left out in the cold, who bookstores ignore until they themselves feel the crunch of people making rational financial decisions.
Don’t get me wrong. I want small bookstores. I think we need them. But we need them to be something only they can uniquely become–involved and participating in their book communities and offering uniqueness, taking risks and becoming partners in local promotion. Not passive vendors with no clear system of access.
[...] Yeah, I am gonna spend a little more on books from this group than Amazon or another group like that, but I am always reminding myself, low costs almost never come without someone else paying the “price.” [...]
[...] Thoughts on Buying Textbooks [...]